American
Diabetes Association's 69th Scientific Sessions
While knowledge of peripheral arterial disease has
progressed, still much is needed in the way of comparator trials and
diagnostics.
PAD – also referred to as peripheral vascular
disease or PVD – affects more than 9 million Americans and more than 10
million in Europe, according to Alan T. Hirsch, MD, director of the
vascular medicine program at Minneapolis Heart Institute.
“PAD is one of the most prevalent, morbid and
mortal cardiovascular diseases,” he said. “The cost of PAD is as high
and likely higher than any other CVD.”
PAD is also a marker for atherosclerosis and a predictor
of death, myocardial infarction or stroke. Add diabetes into the mix and,
“patients with diabetes are at the highest risk,” Hirsch said.
Reena L. Pande, MD, a fellow in vascular
medicine, cardiovascular division, at Brigham & Women’s Hospital, said
available literature shows that half the people with PAD demonstrate symptoms
of metabolic syndrome, which appears in 52% of patients with PAD. Insulin
resistance was linked to PAD in NHANES, and Pande said it is no surprise that
inflammation – which is linked to insulin resistance – is also
related to PAD. The Edinburgh Artery Study shows that patients with diabetes
and glucose intolerance have a higher risk for PAD.
“Diabetes increases the risk of amputation and
death in patients with PAD,” Pande added.
She said that whether improving insulin resistance would
improve outcomes in PAD has not yet been proven, although reducing inflammation
with statins has demonstrated a reduction in incidence of claudication,
improved walking distance and resulted in more pain-free walking.
“Limitations in nutrient uptake into the exercising
skeletal muscle may well impair function and exercise ability in patients with
PAD, so theoretically it makes sense that if we can improve insulin sensitivity
in the level of the skeletal muscle in the lower extremity that we may be able
to get patients walking further and walking with less discomfort. But that data
is not yet known,” Pande said.
In other areas of PAD research, it remains unknown what
biomarkers are specific to PAD. There are available biomarkers – like
endothelial progenitor cells – but none specifically for PAD.
PAD is diagnosed by ankle brachial index, but John
Cooke, MD, PhD, professor of medicine at Stanford University, said that
routine screening is not done and one-third of Americans with PAD are
undiagnosed.
“Ankle brachial index is the current gold standard,
[but] it is not being utilized. If we had a blood test for PAD< there would
be much higher throughput,” Cooke said.
He said biomarker research is at an early stage, but
researchers are hoping to find biomarkers that will lead to better diagnostic
tests, better pathophysiological understanding and potential therapeutic
targets.
Research into protein biomarkers has shown promise.
Cooke said he and colleagues are working on a bead technique to equalize
proteins in plasma to have a better chance at finding the right flags for PAD.
“We’ve got a long way to go; it’s very
early in the field right now,” Cooke said. “What we’re looking
for is a panel that reflects multiple processes that are occurring locally in
skeletal muscle circulating systemically.”
In other areas of PAD diagnostics, Chris M. Kramer,
MD, professor of medicine and radiology, director of the CV imaging center
at the University of Virginia Health System, and colleagues are developing new
MRI-based methods for clinical trials in PAD.
“Instead of just exercise, we’re measuring
perfusion reserves, baseline to exercise, that may even be a more accurate
assessment of PAD,” Kramer said.
Kramer said one of the methods includes an ergometer
attached to an MRI machine that allows moving measurement of the patient limbs.
The researchers are addressing the issue of gadolidium intolerance by
developing techniques that do not require contrast but are still MRI-based.
Results of a trial using multi-modality MRI to test the
efficacy of lipid-lowering therapy on the vessel wall, and atherosclerotic
plaque is scheduled to appear in the August issue of the Journal of the
American College of Cardiology, Kramer said.
Hirsch addressed the need for clinical trials that
determine the best course of treatment for PAD. He put out a plea to
cardiologists and endocrinologists to consider enrolling patients who have
claudication, aortic iliac disease and, if applicable, diabetes into the CLEVER
trial. The trial will compare revascularization and exercise in treatment of
PAD, but Hirsch said recruitment has not gone well since it started in 2007.
He said patients will receive free cilostazol (Pletal,
Otsuka Pharmaceuticals) throughout the study and have access to educational
materials on diet, exercise and risk factors. Those who undergo exercise
therapy will have supervised exercise for six months.
“This trial is not going that great,” Hirsch
said of enrollment. “This is the hardest thing I have ever done in my life
… If you live in a city that has a CLEVER investigator and you have a
patient with iliac disease, we would like your help.”
Interested physicians can visit the trial’s website
for a contact phone number and more information.
“We need PAD trials that are uniquely different
from everything that has happened before … multicenter, including all
relevant treatment strategies,” Hirsh said. Not just stent vs. no stent,
but stent vs. exercise, stent vs. pharmacotherapy, with an effort to include
more women and minorities.
“One of the things that strikes me … is how
much the disease knowledge base has enhanced,” he said. “I do worry
that we may not have transferred this to the bedside.” – by Judith
Rusk
For more information: